Year 9 Reading: Critical_evaluation

The writer uses the statistic that a returned item generates 'four times the emissions' of an unreturned one. What assumption must be true for this statistic to effectively support the writer's argument?

All five states show rising incarceration rates between 2018 and 2023, while crime rates slightly declined in all five. A politician concludes: 'This graph proves that higher incarceration reduces crime.' Which is the most accurate evaluation of this claim?

The writer claims pilot programs show people 'do not' stop working when given UBI. Which is the strongest limitation of this evidence?

A student claims: 'The graph proves that older Australians will all own smartphones within ten years.' Which is the strongest objection to this claim?

The writer states the claim that algorithms are 'neutral conduits of user preference has been thoroughly discredited.' What is missing from this assertion that would strengthen it most?

A researcher claims: 'This graph proves that empathy is the primary driver of charitable giving.' What is the most precise limitation of this claim?

The writer states the $17.9 billion figure and then adds 'This figure has not declined.' Why is the second sentence significant to the argument?

The graph is described as showing content coded as 'predominantly accurate' or 'predominantly inaccurate.' What is the most significant methodological concern with this categorisation?